You are hereДискуссионное сочинение

Дискуссионное сочинение


План урока по подготовке учащихся к выполнению письменного задания С2

Дискуссионное сочинение.

Тип: “For and Against”

1. Вступительная часть. 5 минут.

На доске – тема сочинения и таблица.

Например:

Is it better to be brought up in a large or small family?

Paragraph

Aim of the paragraph

Points to make

1



2



3



4



2.  Whole class activity. 15 минут.

Вмести с учащимися учитель заполняет таблицу.

Важно: учитель не подсазывает идеи, а лишь обьясняет цель каждого абзаца.

Если учащиеся затрудняются предложить «сильный аргумент», то следует их аккуратно подвести к идее, а не подсказывать ее. Так же можно помочь выбрать лучшие аргументы из нескольких предложенных.

При обсуждении 4-го абзаца, необходимо договориться, какое мнение будет представлено в заключении. При расхождении мнений, возможно голосование или принятие компромиссного решения.

Paragraph

Aim of the paragraph

Points to make

1

Introduction

A big role played by a family on individual development

2

Arguments against a big family

1. Children lack parent's attention and fight with each other for it.

2. Without enough love they develpe negative attitude to the world.

3

Arguments for a big family

1. Children lean to share and be cooperative.

2. They are not spoilt.

4

Conclusion

Our opinion: success depends on parents.

3. Group work. 5-7 минут.

Разделить учащихся на 4 группы. Каждая группа пишет один абзац.

4. Заключительная часть. 5-10 минут.

Каждая группа читает свою часть. Учащиеся из других групп оценивают работу. Затем оценку дает учитель.

Дискуссионное счинение.

Is it better to be brought up in a large or small family?

A crucial role in individual’s development is played by his or her family. Parents and relatives do have a great impact on the personality of their children. It is not easy to decide whether a relatively large family improves or worsens the upbringing of children.

Many people believe that big families produce difficult relations between their members. In the first place, children in such families often need more attention and frequently fight with each other as a result. They may even hate their little brothers or sisters if parents spend too mush time on them. What is more, the children in similar situations tend to hide their true feelings. Without enough love and understanding, they grow up with negative attitude toward everyone and can never fill up the empty corner of their heart.

On the other hand, large families do not always cause these problems. While living together, children learn to share, play in groups, take care of each other, and be creative, considerate and cooperative. They very early get the sense of how to communicate with people round them. Besides, there is a little chance of those children to become spoiled or selfish.

In our view, it is not realistic to condemn big families for ineffectiveness. The success depends on the values of every relative. Provided that they all want to create loving atmosphere, nobody would feel lonely or left-out.

11a класс.

Учитель – Сотникова Елена Юрьевна.

The same approach can be used to teach writing an opinion essay.